UDRP.Tools Logo

Panelist Research: Thomas Webster

Decision Report (Total: 57)

Solo Results (42)

Group Results (15)

Decisions by Year Solo

Decisions by Year Group

Panelists Served With

Name TransferComplaint deniedTransfer with dissenting opinionComplaint denied with dissenting opinionComplaint denied, transfer in part with dissenting opinionTotal
Edward C Chiasson22
Pravin Anand22
Nels T Lippert22
David E Sorkin112
Peter L Michaelson11
Michelle Brownlee11
M Scott Donahey11
Charles Gielen11
James Carmody11
Christian Gassauer Fleissner11
W David Quinto11
Mark Partridge11
Jonas Gulliksson11
James W Dabney11
Hugues G Richard11
John Swinson11
Isabelle Leroux11
Neil A Smith11
Peter G Nitter11
Kiyoshi Tsuru11
Katalin Szamosi11
David H Bernstein11
Daniel J Gervais11
Christiane Feral Schuhl11
Jonathan Turner11
William Lobelson11
Show All

Citations Used

As a Solo Panelist

CaseCitationsPanelist(s)PartiesDomainDecision
D2004-11019Michael A AlbertLilly Icos v. East Coast Webscialis-buy.comTransfer
D2000-00038Andrew F ChristieTelstra v. Nuclear Marshmallowstelstra.orgTransfer
D2004-08917Michael C PrylesLilly Icos v. Jay Kimbuy-cialis-a.bizTransfer
D2000-14937Richard W PageMicrosoft v. J Holiday Co4microsoft2000.comTransfer
D2000-06647Mark PartridgeCostco Wholesalethe Price Company v. Price Club A K A Tsung Pei Changpriceclub.comTransfer
D2004-07506Gregory N AlbrightLilly Icos v. Dan Ecclescialis-drug-online-buying-guide.comTransfer
D2000-06305Terrell C BirchMetabolife International v. Robert Williamsmetabolive.comTransfer
D2000-04135Dennis A Foster,
David H Bernstein,
Mark Partridge		Chanel v. Estco Enterprises Estco Technology Groupchanelfashion.comTransfer
D2004-07944Nathalie DreyfusLilly Icos v. Tudor Burden Burden Marketingcialisapcalis.comCancellation
D2000-08344Frederick M AbbottCbs Broadcasting v. Worldwide Websilovelucy.comTransfer
D2004-04873Markus S BonairDeutsche Telekom Ag v. Britt Cordonbild-t-online.infoTransfer
D2001-11423Dennis A FosterChevron v. Young Wook Kimchevron-texaco.comTransfer
D2002-07933Frederick M AbbottPfizer v. Martin Marketingviagra-nascar.comTransfer
D2000-03053Christian Andre Le StancGa Modefine S A v. Armani International Investmentsarmaniinternational.netTransfer
D2000-12702Alan LimburyPorto Chico Stores v. Lovely Girlsotavio Zambonlovelygirls.comComplaint denied
D2002-07442Warwick SmithGorstew v. Worldwidewebsales Comanguillabeaches.comComplaint denied
D2000-18092Mark PartridgeChanel v. Cologne Zonechanelperfumes.comTransfer
D2000-01372Tom ArnoldExpedia v. European Travel Networkxpediatravel.comTransfer
D2000-07002David PlantMarch Madness Athletic Associationnational Collegiate Athletic Association v. Front Center Entertainmentmark Halpernfinal-four.orgTransfer
D2000-12212Frank L PolitanoCliff Greenhouse Keith Greenhousepavillion Agency v. Glenn Greenhousegreenhouse Agencycliffgreenhouse.comTransfer
D2000-10052M Scott DonaheyAsphalt Research Technology v. National Press Publishingezstreet.netComplaint denied
D2000-02352David PerkinsJeanette Winterson v. Mark Hogarthjeanettewinterson.comTransfer
D2000-05872M Scott DonaheyGeocitiesyahoo v. Data Art Dataart Enterprises Stonybrook Investments Global Net 2000 Powerclick Yahoo Searchayhoo.comTransfer
D2000-01632Ian BarkerVeuve Clicquot Ponsardin Maison Fondee En 1772 v. The Polygenix Group Coveuveclicquot.orgTransfer
D2000-00112Charles GielenRonson v. Unimetal Sanayi Ve Tic A Sronson.comTransfer
D2000-05692Richard W PageUniversal City Studios v. Antonio Paezcalle13.comTransfer
D2000-00072Sally AbelAlcoholics Anonymous World Services v. Lauren Raymondalcoholicsanonymous.netTransfer
D2005-04492Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Abadia Distributioncialis411.comTransfer
D2000-04162David H BernsteinUniversal City Studios v. G A B Enterprisesfieldofdreams.comTransfer
D2003-08702David J A CairnsPfizer v. The Magic Islandsviagraconfidential.comTransfer
D2004-01681G XueJardine Motors Group Holdings v. Zung Fu Kuenzungfu.comTransfer
D2001-00631Frederick M AbbottExpress Messenger Systems v. Golden State Overnight Delivery Servicecaliforniaovernight.comTransfer
D2005-09661Lorelei RitchieTelemundo Network Group v. Laporte Holdingsmundostv.comTransfer
D2000-02261Geert GlasParfums Christian Dior S A v. Christiandior Netjavier Garcia Quintaschristiandior.comTransfer
D2004-07531Warwick Smith,
Dawn Osborne,
David E Sorkin		Cassava Enterprises Gibraltar Cassava Enterprises v. Victor Chandler Internationalvictor888.comComplaint denied
D2000-00761Roberto BianchiInfospace Com v. Hari Prakashindiainfospace.comTransfer
D2000-05751Hugues G RichardCrux Scientific Publishers Bvba v. W Fredric Islercrux.netTransfer
D2000-15661Ross WilsonLogicalogica Uk v. Cpic Netlogica-pdv.comTransfer
D2001-01951Richard W PageYahoo v. Cpic Net Micsyed Hussainebay-yahoo.comTransfer
D2006-02501Warwick Smith,
Pierre Yves Gautier,
David E Sorkin		Jet Marques v. Vertical Axisjettour.comComplaint denied
D2001-06101Joan Clark O CWomen In Military Service For America Memorial Foundation v. Russian Web Marketingwimsa.orgTransfer
D2000-11391Thomas L CreelVerisign v. Domainmarksvrsn.comTransfer
D2000-03301Jeffrey M SamuelsEncyclopaedia Britannica v. John Zuccarinithe Cupcake Patrol A K A Country Walk A K A Cupcake Partybitannica.comTransfer
D2003-06961Kiyoshi TsuruPepsico v. Pepsi Srl A K A P E P S I And Ems Computer Industry A K A Emspepsiadventure.comTransfer
D2000-04331Richard W PageEmi Grouptime Warner v. Cpic Netemiwarnermusic.comTransfer
D2007-18861Matthew S HarrisMrs Eva Padberg v. Euroboxeva-padberg.comTransfer
D2001-10861Jacques A LegerEli Lilly Co v. Xigris Internet Servicesxigris.comTransfer
D2001-02131Ian Barker,
Dennis A Foster,
David E Wagoner		Adt Services Ag v. Adtsucks Comadtsucks.comTransfer
D2003-05111Angela FoxU Haul International v. Affordable Web Productionsuhaulmovingtruck.comTransfer
D2001-03261Bernhard MeyerOlivetti S P A v. Cpic Netolivettitecnost.comTransfer
D2000-07161William L MathisUniversal City Studios v. Harper Stephensuniversalstudiosstore.comTransfer
D2000-16001Tony WilloughbyDouble T Radio v. Michael Lopezttfm.comTransfer
D2000-01051Frederick M Abbott,
David H Bernstein,
David M Kelly		Pet Warehouse v. Petwarehouse Competwarehouse.comComplaint denied
D2000-06681Jeffrey M SamuelsSalomon Smith Barney v. Salomon Internet Servicessalomonbrothers.comTransfer
D2000-02101Richard W Page,
Sally Abel,
James Bridgeman		Julia Fiona Roberts v. Russell Boydjuliaroberts.comTransfer
D2003-04651Michael A AlbertBerlitz Investment v. Stefan Tinculescuberlitzsucks.comTransfer
D2001-00511Alan LimburyYahoo v. Yahoo Asian Coyahoo-asian.comTransfer
D2000-13211Thomas WebsterLa Societe Des Bains De Mer Et Du Cercle Des Etrangers A Monaco v. Worldnet Companiescasino-monte-carlo.netTransfer
D2000-04041James BridgemanInstitut Straumann Ag v. Core Ventstraumann-clone.comCancellation
D2000-02541David PlantCbs Broadcasting v. Bert Grovescbswww.comTransfer
D2004-06131Richard W PageForte Communications v. Service For Lifeserviceforlife.comTransfer
D2000-04411Andrew F ChristieReuters v. Global Net 2000 Global Net 2000 A K A Reutersnews Comreters.comTransfer
D2000-07151Ian Barker,
David E Sorkin,
Jose Pio Tamassia Santos		Desportos Licenciamentosa v. David Sallensallen Enterprises Jd Sallen Enterprisescruzeiro.comTransfer
D2003-02771Dennis A FosterSealite v. Carmanah Technologiessealite.comComplaint denied
D2005-04751Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Tommy Hillingermycialispharmacy.comTransfer
D2004-05111Robert A BadgleyDell v. Nonedellcomputersclone.comTransfer
D2000-01961Bernhard MeyerAugust Storck Kg v. Tony Mohamedwerthersoriginal.comTransfer
D2004-05701Luca BarberoBank For International Settlements v. G I Joebfois.orgTransfer
D2000-13701Massimo IntrovigneNutrexpa S A v. Vesateccolacao.comTransfer
D2001-08141Ian BarkerVillage Resorts v. Steven Liebermansuperfares.netComplaint denied
D2000-00241Charles GielenEasyjet Airline Company v. Andrew Steggleseasy Jet Vacuumseasyjet.netTransfer
D2005-13231W Scott Blackmer,
James Bridgeman,
Tony Willoughby		Metropolitan Life Insurance Company v. Hlp General Partnersmet-art.comComplaint denied
D2000-00371Katalin SzamosiZwack Unicum Rt v. Erica J Dunazwackunicum.comTransfer
D2004-03831Richard G LyonBrooke Bollea A K A Brooke Hogan v. Robert Mcgowanbrookehogan.comComplaint denied
D2000-07321Marino PorzioSigla Sistema Globo De Gravacoes Audio Visuaisa v. Italo De Barros Naddeosomlivre.comTransfer
D2003-02971Pravin Anand,
Jeffrey M Samuels,
David E Sorkin		Furtureworld Consultancy v. Online Advicefutureworld.comComplaint denied
D2000-01861Torsten BettingerLibro Ag v. Global Linklibro.comComplaint denied
D2004-04981Wolter Wefers BettinkVolkswagen Ag v. David S Volkswagen Pagevolkswagen.orgTransfer
D2005-04721Andrew MansfieldBrown Sharpe C E Johansson Hexagon Abhexagon Holdings Hexagon Metrology Abhexagon Metrologyhexagon Metrology Nordic Abhexagon Metrology Sparomer Sheffield Measurement Wilcox Associates v. Xspect Solutionsbns-cmm.comTransfer
D2002-00011James BridgemanNokia v. Nick Holmesnokiaheaven-uk.comTransfer
D2001-06031Philip N ArgyViacom International v. Abraham Godongradiomtv.comTransfer
D2005-10681Neil BrownChung Mong Koohyundai Motor Company v. Individualchungmongku.comTransfer
D2000-00161Wolter Wefers BettinkAllocation Network v. Steve Gregoryallocation.comComplaint denied
D2000-01181Frederick M AbbottChargers Football Companynational Football League Properties v. One Sex Entertainment Company And One Sex Entertainment Company A K A Chargergirls Netchargergirls.comTransfer
D2005-01651Daniel J Gervais,
Frederick M Abbott,
Jacques A Leger		Societe Pour L Oeuvre Et La Memoire D Antoine De Saint Exupery Succession Saint Exupery D Agay v. The Holding Companyantoinedesaintexupery.comTransfer
D2000-06311Richard W PageSunfest Of Palm Beach County v. Electronic System Technologies Sunfest Netsunfest.comTransfer
D2002-10641Bradley FreedmanThe Vanguard Group v. Lorna Kangvanguar.comTransfer
D2000-00691Mark PartridgeInfospace Com v. Registrar Administratorwwwinfospaces.comTransfer

As Part of a Three-Member Panel

CaseCitationsPanelist(s)PartiesDomainDecision
D2000-07163William L MathisUniversal City Studios v. Harper Stephensuniversalstudiosstore.comTransfer
D2003-01452Richard G LyonThe Sportsman S Guide v. Vipercomsportsmanguides.comTransfer
D2000-13742Hugues G RichardAmerica Online v. Xianfeng Fuicq502.comTransfer
D2000-12212Frank L PolitanoCliff Greenhouse Keith Greenhousepavillion Agency v. Glenn Greenhousegreenhouse Agencycliffgreenhouse.comTransfer
D2002-06352Richard G Lyon,
Cecil O D Branson,
David E Sorkin		Classmates Online v. John Zuccarini Raveclubclassmat.comTransfer
D2004-09301Peter L MichaelsonTrue Blue Productions v. Chris Hoffmanfatactress.comTransfer
D2004-07191J Nelson LandryLifetime Products v. Iq Managementlifetimeproducts.comTransfer
D2000-14151David H Bernstein,
Sally Abel,
Natasha Lisman		Nicole Kidman v. Cupcake Partyjohn Zuccarininicholekidman.comTransfer
D2000-01311David PerkinsSeekamerica Networks v. Tariq Masood And Solo Signsseek-america.comTransfer
D2003-06911Daniel J GervaisMuseum Of Science v. Asia Venturesmuseumofscienceboston.comTransfer
D2000-00031Andrew F ChristieTelstra v. Nuclear Marshmallowstelstra.orgTransfer
D2006-05601Frederick M Abbott,
Sally Abel,
David E Sorkin		Tom Cruise v. Alberta Hot Rodstomcruise.comTransfer
D2000-05811David H BernsteinRita Rudner v. Internetcoritarudner.comTransfer
D2000-00501Andrew F ChristieThe British Broadcasting v. Jaime Renteriabbcdelondres.comTransfer
D2000-00151William R CornishBennett Coleman Co v. Long Distance Telephone Companythetimesofindia.comTransfer
D2004-00021M Scott Donahey,
Lynda M Braun,
Jeffrey M Samuels		Panavision Panavision International L P v. Domains By Proxy Panavisions Eyewear And Sunglassespanavisions.comTransfer
D2004-08981Peter L MichaelsonPelmorex Communications v. Weathernetworkweathernetwork.comTransfer
D2000-06851Jeffrey M SamuelsUniversal Studios Universal City Studios Vivendi S A The Seagram Company Joseph E Seagram Sons v. Cpic Netevivendiuniversal.comTransfer
D2000-02701David H Bernstein,
Andrew F Christie,
Christopher P Tootal		Document Technologies v. International Electronic Communicationshtmlease.comComplaint denied
D2001-02181Jeffrey M SamuelsThe Professional Golfers Association Of America v. Golf Fitness A K A Golf Fitness Associationpgamagazine.comTransfer
D2000-00141William R CornishBennett Coleman Co v. Steven S Lalwanitheeconomictimes.comTransfer
D2004-08361Peter L MichaelsonLockheed Martin v. Deborah Teramaniaa-skunk-works.comTransfer
D2000-02491Ian BarkerAt T v. Tala Alamuddinatt2000.comTransfer
D2001-01681Hariram JayaramKeppel Tatlee Bank v. Lars Taylorkeppelbank.comTransfer
D2002-09691Henry Perritt,
G Gervaise Davis,
Jette Robsahm		Citigroup v. Joseph Parvincitifinance.comComplaint denied, transfer in part with dissenting opinion
D2002-00871Philip N Argy,
Ian Barker,
David E Sorkin		Pwc Business Trust v. Ultimate Searchpwc.comComplaint denied
D2000-17781Jonathan TurnerKoninklijke Philips Electronics N V v. Mr Cun Siang Wangphilips-indonesia.comComplaint denied
D2000-02351David PerkinsJeanette Winterson v. Mark Hogarthjeanettewinterson.comTransfer
D2000-12771M Scott Donahey,
David H Bernstein,
Jeffrey M Samuels		Buhl Optical Co v. Mailbank Combuhl.comComplaint denied
D2002-07861David H Bernstein,
Staniforth Ricketson,
David E Sorkin		Australian Trade Commission v. Matthew Readeraustrade.comTransfer
D2002-06051Peter L MichaelsonAt T v. Roman Abreusmartalkwireless.comTransfer
D2000-01871Matthew D Powers,
Richard W Page,
Jordan S Weinstein		Weber Stephen Products Co v. Armitage Hardwareweber-grill.comComplaint denied
D2000-02101Richard W Page,
Sally Abel,
James Bridgeman		Julia Fiona Roberts v. Russell Boydjuliaroberts.comTransfer
D2000-12101David H Bernstein,
Frederick M Abbott,
David Maher		Religion Raelienne De Francereligion Raelienne Internationale v. Mailbank Comrael.comComplaint denied
D2003-03231Nick J Gardner,
Michael A Albert,
David E Sorkin		Career Guidance Foundation v. Ultimate Searchcollegesource.comComplaint denied
D2002-07261Tony Willoughby,
Alberto De Elzaburu,
M Scott Donahey		Galatasaray Sportif Sinai Ve Ticari Yatirimlar A S Galatasaray Pazarlama A S Galatasaray Spor Kulubu Dernegi v. Maksimum Iletisim Hizmetleri A Sgalatasaray.comTransfer
D2002-05351Warwick Smith,
David E Sorkin,
Tony Willoughby		Sustainable Forestry Management v. James M Van Johnssfm.comComplaint denied with concurring opinion
D2001-09031David H BernsteinOki Data Americas v. Asdinc Comokidataparts.comComplaint denied
D2000-08341Frederick M AbbottCbs Broadcasting v. Worldwide Websilovelucy.comTransfer
D2002-01411Peter L MichaelsonPeter Frampton v. Frampton Enterprisespeterframpton.comTransfer
D2000-01181Frederick M AbbottChargers Football Companynational Football League Properties v. One Sex Entertainment Company And One Sex Entertainment Company A K A Chargergirls Netchargergirls.comTransfer
D2000-04541Frederick M AbbottAmerican Home Products v. Healthy Futuresamericanhomeproductscorporation.comTransfer
D2002-00051Richard W PageUnited Artists Theatre Circuit v. Domains For Saleunitedartiststheatres.comTransfer
D2000-00361Anne Virginie La Spada GaideEfg Bank European Financial Group Sa v. Jacob Foundationefgpb.comTransfer
D2003-06151Peter L MichaelsonCaesars World Cwi Park Place Entertainment Park Place v. Japan Nipponcaesarsentertain.comTransfer
D2000-00241Charles GielenEasyjet Airline Company v. Andrew Steggleseasy Jet Vacuumseasyjet.netTransfer
D2000-01381David H BernsteinQuixtar Investments v. Scott A Smithberger A K A Scott Smithy And Quixtar Iboquixtar-sign-up.comTransfer
D2000-02291Young KimCho Yong Pil v. Imagelandchoyongpil.comTransfer
D2003-08211Frank SchoneveldShell International Petroleum Company v. Allen Jonesshell-nigeria.comTransfer

Decisions Cited by Others

As a Solo Panelist

CaseCitationsPanelist(s)PartiesDomainDecision
D2005-0694143Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. John Hopking Neo Netbestcialisnow.comTransfer
D2005-031344Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Tudor Burden Bm Marketing Burden Marketingadvantagecialis.comTransfer, cancellation in part
D2004-098639Thomas WebsterSix Continents Hotels v. Midas Searchwatsonvilleholidayinn.comTransfer
D2000-127416Thomas WebsterMicrosoft v. Stoneybrookwwwmicrosoft.comTransfer
D2001-124612Thomas WebsterL Air Liquide v. Mr Syed Hussain Micsuezairliquid.comTransfer
D2000-135012Thomas WebsterClub Mediterranee S A v. Yosi Hasidimclub-med.comTransfer
D2001-093710Thomas WebsterEdmunds Com v. Wwwedmunds Comdmunds.comTransfer
D2005-05809Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Sachin Tailorcialisclones.comTransfer
D2001-14317Thomas WebsterDeloitte Touche Tohmatsu v. Robert Thorpdeloittetouche.netTransfer
D2005-04496Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Abadia Distributioncialis411.comTransfer
D2005-05346Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Redzonecialisprescrips.comTransfer
D2005-04756Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Tommy Hillingermycialispharmacy.comTransfer
D2001-05876Thomas WebsterDonna Karan Studio v. Raymond Donndknyjeans.comTransfer
D2005-03755Thomas WebsterCanadian Tire v. Juancho Felicianocantire.bizTransfer
D2000-14015Thomas WebsterBsa v. Paul Tweedbridel.comTransfer
D2000-18325Thomas WebsterChanel v. Designer Exposurechanelaccessories.comTransfer
D2006-13194Thomas WebsterThe Hartz Mountain v. Whois Id Theft Protectionwardley.comTransfer
D2005-04824Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Idesignsgreat-cialis-viagra.bizCancellation
D2004-05454Thomas WebsterGovernment Employees Insurance Company Geico v. Gicogico.comTransfer
D2005-04364Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Lei Lubuycheapcialis.netTransfer
D2000-13213Thomas WebsterLa Societe Des Bains De Mer Et Du Cercle Des Etrangers A Monaco v. Worldnet Companiescasino-monte-carlo.netTransfer
D2001-06653Thomas WebsterLa Societe Batigere Sa v. Sociedad Batigerebatigere.comComplaint denied
D2001-06072Thomas WebsterIcstis v. International Commercial Software Training It Support Roy Devaneyicstis.comComplaint denied
D2001-02472Thomas WebsterBernardaud N A Bernardaud Porcelaines De Limoges S A v. Chapman Capitalbernardaud.comComplaint denied
D2005-03762Thomas WebsterLilly Icos v. Megasys Yoginder Manchanda Yahoo Comcialis-ed.comTransfer
D2009-04411Thomas WebsterTpi Holdings v. Michael Jaypayments-autotrader.comTransfer
D2001-00711Thomas WebsterLaurence Fontaine v. Visiotex Salauresainclair.comTransfer
D2004-00311Thomas WebsterAsco Grouppentland Usa v. Garth Marriotkangaroosusa.comTransfer
D2000-17641Thomas WebsterKoc Holdings A S v. Marketweb A Skoc.comComplaint denied

As Part of a Three-Member Panel

CaseCitationsPanelist(s)PartiesDomainDecision
D2001-0110405Thomas Webster,
Mark Partridge,
John Swinson		Ansell Healthcare Products v. Australian Therapeutic Suppliesansellcondoms.comTransfer
D2005-111611Thomas Webster,
M Scott Donahey,
Charles Gielen		The Dutch Private Company With Liability Cnr Music B V v. High Performance Networksarcade.comComplaint denied
D2005-002710Thomas Webster,
William Lobelson,
Jonathan Turner		Deutsche Telekom Ag v. Mighty Domain Admintmobil.comTransfer
D2001-00599Thomas Webster,
David H Bernstein,
Katalin Szamosi		Patricia Ford Online Creations v. Damir Kruzicevicpatricia-ford.comTransfer
D2001-03413Thomas Webster,
Neil A Smith,
Kiyoshi Tsuru		Jose De Jesus Velazquez Jimenez v. Mailbank Comvelazquez.comComplaint denied
D2004-01632Thomas Webster,
James Carmody,
David E Sorkin		Lawfinders Associates v. Ultimate Searchlawfinder.comComplaint denied
D2005-11342Peter L Michaelson,
Michelle Brownlee,
Thomas Webster		Whm L L C v. Northpointelconquistadorresort.comComplaint denied, transfer in part with dissenting opinion
D2004-02401Thomas Webster,
Christiane Feral Schuhl,
Daniel J Gervais		Inter Power A K v. Entreprises Larrycompresseurquebec.comTransfer
D2000-11091Edward C Chiasson,
Hugues G Richard,
Thomas Webster		Hugo Boss A G v. Dr Yang Consultingmyhugoboss.comTransfer
D2006-01201Thomas Webster,
Peter G Nitter,
David E Sorkin		2018120 Ontario Dba Battlegoat Studios v. Port Mediasupremeruler.comTransfer with dissenting opinion
D2006-05341Thomas Webster,
Christian Gassauer Fleissner,
W David Quinto		Bawag P S K Bank v. Future Mediapsk.comComplaint denied with dissenting opinion